top of page

Part 6: Kaizen and Kaikaku – When is improvement sufficient and when is renewal is necessary?

Nov 9
8 min read
Woman in the forest at a Kaizen/Kaikaku signpost; autumn mountains in the background, text below: Kaizen or Kaikaku…


In the same week, a Kaizen workshop is held, followed by a long, intensive discussion about complete change: I'm very familiar with this from many companies. Both are acceptable, but they shouldn't be confused.

Because as soon as improvement and innovation are lumped together, you end up in one of two dead ends: Either only the big picture counts, or things continue in piecemeal fashion without anyone checking whether the assumptions are still valid.

Japanese business practices employ two distinct concepts: Kaizen focuses on improving existing systems, while Kaikaku challenges the system itself. Those who fail to distinguish between these two remain busy but stagnate.


Today, in part 6 of the Japanese Innovation Map ( link to the other parts ), I will address two principles that aim to answer the question: When is improvement sufficient and when is renewal necessary?



Japanese Innovation Map: Slide titled IMPROVEMENT and text on 9 Kaizen/PDCA and 10 Kaikaku/Blue Ocean Strategy on a light map background.
Cluster "Improvement" of the Japanese Innovation Map

Kaizen – Change in small steps


Kaizen (改善) means "change for the better." In Japanese manufacturing companies, it's a word deeply ingrained in everyday practice. Here, however, it's often associated with a series of workshops: target vision, approach, planning, kick-off, and conclusion. After that, Kaizen is added to the action plan. And... not much happens. I've seen this far too often.

The story is almost a bit crazy, because the impetus came from the USA after the war, primarily through W. Edward Deming . However, it received little attention there. In Japan, on the other hand, it did. At Toyota , Taiichi Ohno turned it into a new rule for operations: If you see a deviation, you identify it, correct it, test the effect, and provide feedback again. This way, a small step is taken today, not just next quarter. And it's visible and verifiable. More on the philosophy behind these small things can be found in "Kaizen Meets Shinto ."


Kaizen in Innovation Management


In the day-to-day realm of innovation, you don't recognize Kaizen by the size of the idea, but by the question behind it. It's not: "What would be the next big thing?", but: "What's possible within this scope, with this team, this week?"

In SMEs, this shouldn't be interpreted as a lack of ambition. It's simply the only remaining option when schedules, budget constraints, and fear of failure are already blocking any major breakthrough.


Robot arms assemble a white car body in a bright factory hall, with slight motion blur.
Small improvements add up to greater productivity.

At Toyota and other manufacturing companies, suggestions come from the production line and are tested on-site. A single change is rarely a story in itself, but their cumulative effect certainly is.

PWM, the hidden champion for petrol station price displays, has been developing its technology over the years, progressing from neon systems to electronic signs. No disruption show, just continuous product improvements.


Kaizen doesn't protect you from making mistakes. But it does protect you from waiting for perfect conditions and therefore not starting at all.


Kaikaku – the deliberate break


Where Kaizen improves, Kaikaku fundamentally questions the existing system. Kaikaku (改革) means reform, upheaval, radical change. Kaizen improves ongoing operations. However, at some point, further small steps may only produce residual effects because the problem lies within the framework itself. Kaikaku therefore questions whether this system still makes sense at all.


Kaizen works within the system, Kaikaku works on the system.

Lean authors like Jeffrey Liker describe it succinctly: Continuous improvement has its limits. Then a breakthrough is needed to establish a new foundation. Only then can Kaizen take hold again.


Kaikaku in Innovation Management


In innovation management , this means recognizing and courageously stating when improvements alone are no longer sufficient. Then, systemic renewal is needed. Ohno didn't just fix minor glitches on the assembly line at Toyota. He changed the way production was carried out: Instead of manufacturing and storing large quantities for stock, only what the next step truly requires is produced – and when it's needed. That was the turning point. Only after that did the daily improvement become so effective. Even though Toyota is currently facing significant economic difficulties, the Toyota principle, with its underlying courage to embrace change, remains fundamentally sound and groundbreaking.


Panasonic Holdings 2025 is currently demonstrating the same approach on a large scale with its corporate reform: portfolio reduction, structural reorganization, and a focus on solution- and data-driven businesses. This isn't a matter of fine-tuning, but rather a complete redesign. This includes...

Resistance and ambiguity, but also the chance to no longer maintain an outdated model.

Unfortunately, innovation often means: making improvements with as little risk as possible, accompanied by a big show. Or the bar for innovation is set so high that nobody even starts. Both are a waste.




A bright neon sign reading LET'S CHANGE is placed in front of a building, framed by bare tree branches with yellow leaves.
When improvements no longer help, the only solution is often a radical change..

Kaikaku is painful, and the decision-makers in an organization must have the courage to do it.

Opportunities and risks


Kaizen lowers the barrier to entry. A small step to try things out beats the perfect concept that never gets off the ground. The risk, however, is the token effect: many small activities that suggest innovative power, but lack the necessary decisiveness.

Kaikaku creates a new foundation when the system itself is the problem. The risk here is thinking too big. If the bar is set too high, it creates a lot of anxiety and a safety net loop, which I described in "Out of the Innovation Dead End ." This costs motivation and time.

So how should we proceed?

Three questions are sufficient for better classification:

  • Does the system improve if we refine it? ➡️ Kaizen.

  • Are the framework and basic assumptions no longer appropriate? ➡️ Kaikaku.

  • Is it just about looking more innovative? ❌ Then it's neither.


Nemawashi and Gemba help us to avoid forcing a Kaikaku break in the plenary session, but rather to prepare for it and test it on-site. Shu Ha Ri and Shoshin remind us that expertise and routine often obscure the view of necessary changes.



Stronger together: Kaizen and Kaikaku combined with Western innovation methods


In Western companies, Kaizen and Kaikaku often remain elusive. Their impact becomes apparent when you link them to tools that teams here are already familiar with: PDCA and value stream mapping for small steps, Blue Ocean Analysis and reverse brainstorming for disruptive changes. Then the Japanese principle isn't an exotic idea, but something you can use in your everyday business.



Kaizen + PDCA + Value Stream Mapping


PDCA (Plan-Do-Check-Act) originates from quality management, heavily influenced by W. Edwards Deming, and is also the core of Japanese continuous improvement. You plan a small change, try it out, test the effect, and then standardize or correct it. It's a cycle.

Value stream analysis makes the flow of a service visible: Where is value created, where are waiting times, where are handovers, inventories, and queries? It generates an honest, rational, and objective inventory of the actual process.


These two methods are particularly well suited to Kaizen for these essential reasons:


Both methods are so well-suited to Kaizen because they operationalize improvement without turning it into a campaign. PDCA keeps the steps small and adaptable. Value stream mapping prevents you from becoming "a little bit better" in the wrong place and wasting resources on "pointless improvements," for example, at a station that isn't actually the bottleneck in the overall flow. In idea evaluation, you can more quickly see which idea solves a process problem and which only treats a symptom. In the portfolio, you distinguish between maintaining the existing system and genuine transformation. In daily operations, you gain a foundation for progress, even if no one allocates a specific innovation budget.



Kaikaku + Blue Ocean Strategy + Reverse Brainstorming


Blue Ocean (Kim/Mauborgne) doesn't ask how to better serve a familiar market, but rather which factors disappear, decrease, increase, or emerge, and where competition becomes irrelevant. It's not about fine-tuning the current offering, but about examining the logic of the market itself.

Reverse brainstorming turns the question around: not "How can we do this better?", but "How would we reliably ruin this offer, this process, or this business model?" In my experience, this question sparks great creativity in all teams. The answers then reveal which assumptions remain untouched and which ideas are highly effective and should be specifically reformulated in a positive way.


For these essential reasons, these two methods are particularly well suited to Kaikaku


Both methods are suitable for Kaikaku because they examine the system as a whole, not just a single detail. Blue Ocean prevents "innovation" from becoming merely a better version of what already exists. Reverse brainstorming makes blind spots vulnerable before the major program begins. You gain criteria for when an idea belongs in Kaizen mode and when it affects the portfolio, the market, or the process architecture itself. This reduces the risk of implementing a reform that is, in reality, just optimization, and the risk of dismissing a necessary renewal as "too big."




How-to: Practical application in three examples



Flowering branches in a vase in front of a group at a table; in the background a poster with the Japanese Innovation Map.
Hands-On Workshop Using the Japanese Innovation Map*

Theory only helps us if it actually improves the next meeting. So, how can that be achieved? Here are three situations where Kaizen and Kaikaku are immediately applicable:


  1. Clear direction assessment in idea evaluation and innovation portfolio:

    Match each idea with a simple question: Should it improve upon what already exists, or should/must it change the framework? Kaizen ideas don't require much effort: hypothesis, small test, measurement, standardization, or correction. Kaikaku approaches, on the other hand, belong in a different category: Which offering, which market, which process logic is being questioned here? If you throw both into the same pipeline, the simpler—but not always appropriate—approach always wins. Write two columns on the portfolio board. Left: "Improve." Right: "Innovate." This separation alone changes the discussion.

  2. Courage to improve processes versus radical new development:

    Before you set up a transformation program, analyze the value stream. Do you see waste, handoffs, or waiting times in the existing flow? Then first consider Kaizen with PDCA at the bottleneck. If the value stream shows that the process itself is based on an outdated assumption—for example, "we sell individual items" instead of "we sell availability"—then Kaikaku is due. The rule is straightforward: First determine whether the system is still viable, then decide whether you want to work within it or on it.

  3. The maker's perspective.

    In difficult projects, frustration often consumes entire meetings. What I learned in Japan is that obstacles and frustrations need space, but briefly and objectively. Then the perspective shifts: What options do we have within this framework? What concrete steps can we take now under these circumstances ?

    This results in a small step forward or the realization that a cut is necessary.

More on this in "Out of the Innovation Dead End" . For a better understanding of the different types of innovation, see the blog post "What is Innovation?".



Food for thought


Ultimately, one question remains that is surprisingly rarely asked in the everyday world of innovation: Are you improving or avoiding innovation? Kaizen keeps you capable of acting when room for maneuver is limited. Kaikaku helps you be honest when there is no room for maneuver within the existing framework.

Take a moment. Look at your current portfolio, the last workshop board, a process you've "always" done the way you do it. Which measures are genuine Kaizen? Which ones only pretend to be innovative but achieve nothing? A second question almost follows automatically: Do you have the courage to think about innovation on a smaller scale, or do you set the bar so high that no one even starts?



Frequently Asked Questions


Ask:

Is Kaizen just continuous improvement under a different name?

Answer:

Continuous Improvement (CIP) often consists of workshops, boards, and action lists. But Kaizen reveals itself later: Is an improvement tested on the actual process, is feedback fed back, documented, and discussed regularly? It's about allowing everyone to actually change something! Kaizen is a system built on routine.


Ask:

When will Kaikaku be needed?

Answer:

When further small improvements alone no longer solve the problem, because the framework conditions themselves are the limiting factor.


Ask:

Is both possible in medium-sized businesses?

Answer:

Yes. Not in the same category. Kaizen keeps the business afloat. Kaikaku clarifies where cuts are needed.


The next and seventh part of the series deals with the cluster "Perception" with Ma and Wabi Sabi: "How does innovation affect the organization internally and externally?" Stay tuned. It's worth it!



👉 Here you can find the other blogposts of this series: Japanese Innovation Roadmap



📃Do you want all 12 x 24 principles at a glance?

or

📃Want more details on all the 12 x 24 principles?


Here you will find both free and paid downloads (in German):



*Tagged images created with Grok Imagine by xAI




Dr. Babette Sonntag is an innovation manager, keynote speaker, and "The Innonaut." She helps managers in medium-sized businesses who want to initiate something new but are stuck, using Japanese spirit as a boost.   



Please note: This text is translated into English by using Wix Translation and DeepL- I apologize for any mistakes in this text I may have overlooked.






Comments


bottom of page